Home blogs SMILE Surgery vs LASIK: 7 Differences to Help You Choose

SMILE Surgery vs LASIK: 7 Differences to Help You Choose

Are you tired of glasses or contact lenses? Laser vision correction may be the solution for you. At present two main topics of discussion are LASIK and SMILE surgery. Both which change the cornea, the clear front of the eye, to correct your vision. But they do it in different ways. In this guide which will go over 7 basic differences between the two. Also many will touch on who is a good candidate, what the recovery is like, and what factors into the laser eye surgery cost in India. This will help you have a clear conversation with your eye doctor.

What Is SMILE Surgery?

SMILE is an acronym for Small Incision Lenticule Extraction. In the SMILE surgery a femtosecond laser is used to make a thin lenticular piece of tissue in the cornea. The surgeon then takes out that piece via a very small incision which is usually only 2 to 4 mm in length. What that does is change the cornea’s shape and in turn corrects vision.

There is no flap in SMILE eye surgery. This is the biggest difference from LASIK.

What Is LASIK?

In the course of LASIK the surgeon uses a femtosecond laser or a fine blade to create a thin flap on the cornea. That which is flapped is then lifted to expose the layer under for an excimer laser to reshape it. Finally the flap is put back. What is modern in procedures like that of Contoura Vision which uses the latest LASIK technology is that the treatment is planned out based on the specific shape of your cornea.

The Same Laser Is Used in Cataract Care

The use of femtosecond lasers in eye care is nothing new. They are used in femtosecond laser cataract surgery which is a procedure in which the laser makes precise incisions prior to the removal of the clouded lens. In SMILE surgery may see that the laser has a very wide experience in eye hospitals. While it is true that in femtosecond laser cataract surgery is used for breaking up the lens and its removal, in SMILE it is used to correct the refractive errors which means that they are for the correction of power of the eye. Thus these are very different procedures which have different applications.

7 Differences Between SMILE Surgery and LASIK

Many people ask how SMILE differs from LASIK. Here are the main points.

SMILE vs LASIK at a Glance

PointSMILELASIK
1. Cut sizeSmall cut, about 2–4 mmLarger flap on the cornea
2. Lasers usedOne femtosecond laserFemtosecond or blade, plus excimer laser
3. Dry eyeOften less dry eye in early monthsDry eye is more common early on
4. Flap riskNo flap, so no flap shiftingFlap can shift after a hard hit
5. Powers treatedMainly short-sight and astigmatismShort-sight, long-sight and astigmatism
6. RecoveryQuick, vision may take a few days to sharpenQuick, vision is often clear the next day
7. EnhancementSMILE enhancement surgery is more complexUsually simpler, by lifting the flap

A Closer Look at Recovery

SMILE surgery and LASIK are both done as day care, and most people go home the same day. Learn more about recovery with SMILE and the eye drops you will need.

What About Enhancements?

At times some power may remain which can return at a later date. A second in office procedure may be required. After LASIK it is usual for the surgeon to lift the same flap. With SMILE enhancement surgery this is not the case as there is no flap to lift. It is also often performed via a surface laser method like PRK, or by a method which your surgeon deems best. Ask your doctor how often SMILE enhancement surgery is carried out and what it includes before you make up your mind.

Who Can Have SMILE Eye Surgery?

You may be suitable for SMILE eye surgery if you are an adult with stable glasses power for at least a year and a healthy cornea.

It is equally important to know who is not a candidate. Laser correction may not be advised if you:

  • Have a thin or irregular cornea, such as keratoconus
  • Are pregnant or breastfeeding
  • Have severe dry eye or uncontrolled diabetes
  • Have power that is still changing

If SMILE eye surgery is not right for you, other options like ICL lenses may be discussed.

Understanding Laser Eye Surgery Cost

Laser eye surgery cost are different for each person. It depends on the type of surgery, which laser is used, your eye exams, and the clinic. As a rough guide, SMILE eye surgery cost usually have a higher price point than standard LASIK which is because they use a more advanced laser. Also, Contoura Vision surgery cost than standard LASIK as it includes in depth corneal mapping.

What Affects the Cost?

FactorHow It Affects Cost
Type of procedureSMILE, Contoura and Femto LASIK often cost more than standard LASIK
Pre-surgery testsDetailed corneal maps add to the Contoura Vision surgery cost
Laser platformNewer machines may raise the SMILE eye surgery cost
Follow-up visitsSome packages include follow-up care
Need for touch-upsSMILE enhancement surgery or LASIK touch-ups may add cost

Always ask for a written estimate of the full laser eye surgery cost. Compare what is included in the SMILE eye surgery cost and the Contoura Vision surgery cost, not just the final number.

Conclusion

Both LASIK and SMILE surgery are proven for reducing dependency on glasses. SMILE does a smaller incision and does away with the flap. LASIK has a greater range of treatment and easier touch ups. Laser eye surgery cost and SMILE eye surgery cost depends on your eyes and the method chosen. Also include in your discussion the Contoura Vision surgery price, SMILE enhancement surgery options and recovery. The femtosecond laser cataract surgery also is used in refractive care. To see if SMILE is right for you book an eye check up at Vasan Eye Care.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is the SMILE eye surgery cost worth it?

It depends on your eyes and needs. For some people, the smaller cut and lower flap risk matter a lot.

2. Why is Contoura Vision surgery cost different from LASIK?

Contoura uses detailed corneal mapping to plan a more personalised treatment, which may raise the price.

3. Is SMILE surgery painful?

No. Numbing drops are used. You may feel mild pressure for a short time.

4. Is SMILE the same as femtosecond laser cataract surgery?

No. Both use a femtosecond laser, but femtosecond laser cataract surgery removes a cataract, while SMILE corrects glasses power.

References

  1. Small Incision Lenticule Extraction – StatPearls, National Library of Medicine (NIH)
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK549896/
  2. Laser In Situ Keratomileusis (LASIK) – StatPearls, National Library of Medicine (NIH)
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK555970/

  3. What Should I Expect During and After Surgery? (LASIK) – U.S. Food and Drug Administration
    https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/lasik/what-should-i-expect-during-and-after-surgery
  4. Small Incision Lenticule Extraction (SMILE): History, Fundamentals and Clinical Outcomes – PubMed Central, NIH
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4604118/